How to ask for feedback at work and use it

Ask someone who saw your work for specific advice, then test one change the next time you do a similar task.

A narrow channel runs from a tide pool through flat coastal rocks toward the sea.

“How am I doing?” is a big question to answer on the spot. Pick a recent piece of work and ask about a part you’ll do again. That gives the other person something they can remember and gives you a place to try their suggestion.

Ask someone who saw the part you want to improve

Start with what you want to learn. A colleague who ran the next shift can tell you whether your handoff left them enough to work with. A client who read a proposal can point to the part that raised questions. Your manager is a good person to ask when you need to understand what the role requires or which improvement matters most.

Make the request while the work is still easy to recall. Point to the meeting, document, or handoff and offer a small window of time. For a written request, link to the exact section you want them to look at if they have access to it. Give them room to reply later.

Ask what to do next time

Take one or two of these questions into the conversation.

In a large preregistered field experiment and two lab studies, asking for future-looking advice rather than “feedback” produced more concrete and actionable input. The field experiment covered more than 27,000 written comments. The researchers looked at the comments people gave. Whether a suggestion helps your performance is something to check on the next task (Management Science, checked November 20, 2026).

Ask for an example before you respond

If you hear a broad judgment such as “be more concise,” ask which detail the person would cut or where they stopped following. Summarize what you heard and check that you understood it. Then thank them for the example. You can take time to think about what you’ll do with it.

If an important fact is missing, add it briefly after you’ve heard them out. They may have seen one part of the task and missed a requirement from another team. Find out which problem their suggestion would solve before deciding whether it fits.

Try one change on the next piece of work

Write down what you’ll change, where you’ll try it, and what you’ll look for afterward. Choose something you can see or ask about, such as whether the next reader could find the deadline without asking. If the task comes around regularly, try the change on a comparable version so the result is easier to interpret.

An amber leaf rests on slate where two shallow trickles of water meet.

Illustrative example — Making a handoff easier to use

Suppose you send a Friday handoff to the colleague who opens on Monday. Ask them where they had to look beyond your note to get started and what they’d put at the top next time. If they say the handoff felt scattered, ask what they needed first. In this example, it was the owner of an unresolved order, who was buried in the notes.

For the next two handoffs, put a short list of unresolved orders and who owns each one at the top. When you next overlap, ask whether your colleague could tell who was handling each open order without opening another message. That tells you more about this change than a fresh request to rate the whole handoff.

Common questions

What if two people give me conflicting advice?

Ask what each person needed from the work. A manager who wants a quick decision and a colleague who needs to carry it out may need different levels of detail. If the same document serves both, try a short decision summary with implementation details underneath. If priorities still conflict, ask whoever owns the deliverable to decide which audience comes first.

What if all I hear is that it went well?

Ask which part they’d want you to repeat. A specific answer gives you something to preserve when you change another part of the work.

Sources